Saturday, October 23, 2010

Barber & Styling Scissors - Material Elements, Compositions & Properties of Forged Steel

Deciding to buy a scissor or trying to trouble shoot a scissor that does not cut well is a difficult task. In the past, stores and distributors were much more trained in what they were selling. But in today's sales environment of mass merchandising, most sales people do not know any more about the product they are selling than what is printed on the box, if even that much. If they are not educated, then they cannot educate and assist their customers.

Sharpeners are confronted with myriads of challenges, when trouble shooting and repairing a scissor. One does not just sharpen a $300.00 professional hair cutting scissor like a kitchen scissor. If something is wrong with the scissor, the problem must be analyzed and the best alternative to fix it found. When selling a new scissor to a customer, the sales person must know everything about the scissors, not just the name and what the sales price is, because if he/she doesn't, they will not keep the customers repair business for long. The most important aspects of a scissor are:

1. STEEL - What type of steel alloy the scissor is made from. What grade of steel is it? 300 series, 400 series, etc. This is the general metallurgical composition of the scissor.

2. PROCESS - The processing of this steel. Is it forged, cast, or sintered metal. Was it heat treated correctly, ice tempered, etc.? Even the best steel can be next to useless in a scissor if it is processed badly.

3. MANUFACTURE - The manufacture of the scissor. Is it convexed or beveled. Is it hollow ground? If so, is the rake angle correct, etc.?

All three of these components of a scissor are important. But the first two components, steel and processing are most important, because if the base steel and processing of this steel is not good, then no amount of manufacturing and finishing expertise will help make the scissor good.
Unfortunately, most sharpeners are experts in the sharpening and repair of the scissor, but understand very little of the metallurgy and processing techniques used to manufacture the scissor. A understanding of these techniques will make their jobs easier and their repair and sharpening results better. This paper examines the fundamentals of scissor metallurgy and processing. If you have further questions, need information about various steels, or would like some of our other technical papers for the scissors industry, please do not hesitate to contact Dar Expo. We will be glad to help you.

WHAT IS STEEL? AND WHAT MAKES IT HARD?
When you take iron and add a specific amount of carbon, you can then harden the iron. In other words, steel is hardenable carbonated iron. The degree of hardenablility depends on the amount of carbon added to the mix.



In a simplified explanation, iron forms into a crystalline structure that looks like a bunch of cubes (cells) stacked on top of each other. During the heat treatment of a steel, when the temperature is above 1340oF, there is an iron atom at each corner of the cube and one in the middle of each side of the cube. This type of iron structure is known as a face-centered crystal or AUSTENITE IRON. In the face-centered cubic lattice, a relatively large interstice, or "hole", exists in the center of the cube or cell. When carbon is present in the Austenite iron, the extremely small carbon atom slips into the hole of this iron cell. Then when the steel is quenched (cooled rapidly in oil or water) to room temperature, the iron crystal cell shifts it’s structure to a more stable body centered crystal, also known as FERRITE IRON. In Ferrite Iron there is an iron atom at each corner of the cube and one in the middle of the box. Unfortunately, the carbon is too big to fit comfortably into the open spaces left in center of the box and is forced out into one of the small interstices (holes) left between the Iron atoms. Now the iron structure is always under tension, because the carbon atoms are trapped as an atomic dispersion in its interstices, and thus the iron lattice becomes hard and brittle. This is similar to a fully filled balloon under tension being harder than a half filled balloon, which is tougher and softer.

Because of the small amount of space available, even for the small carbon atom, the solubility of carbon in Ferrite (room temperature structure) is very low (less than 1 carbon per 1000 iron atoms). At high temperatures, the maximum solubility of carbon in Austenite iron is only 2.11%. So by definition, steels contain less than 1.2% carbon, so that the carbon can dissolve completely in Austenite at high temperatures.

Heat Treating:
After the tool is forged or stamped and all of the screw holes have been drilled, the scissor is heated to a high temperature (between 1450o F and 2000o F) Most scissors are heat treated either in a Salt Bath, an Environmental Chamber, or by Induction Heating. Heat treatment may be employed to improve tensile strength, ductility, toughness, wear resistance, machinability, formability, bending quality, corrosion resistance, magnetic properties and others. Heat treating is very fickle and can be a very complicated problem, since quite a large number of different alloys are in the steel, and although not all of them require heat-treatment, many do, with well-defined heating and cooling requirements for each. Steel at room temperature is composed of Ferrite iron, carbides and the other alloying elements in a lamellar microstructure called Pearlite (See picture page 4). As the steel is heated, it reaches a temperature in which the carbides begin to dissolve into the iron. When the temperature reaches a point where all of the carbon is dissolved into the iron we have Austenite Iron again.

The carbon is now very evenly distributed in the Austenite. (In carbon steel cutlery, one can find up to 1% carbon in the steel, but usually only 0.55-0.7 %.) If the Austenite steel is cooled slowly to room temperature, the iron changes to Ferrite and squeezes all of the carbon out of the lattice spaces, since there is less room. The carbon has a tendency to clump together and making long plates of carbon surrounded by Ferrite Iron in a Pearlite structure mentioned before. One now has large areas of soft Ferrite with spots of hard carbon in between. Depending on the amount of carbon in the steel mixture, these areas of carbon can form into CARBIDES (binary carbon areas) or CEMENTITE (a structure of Fe3C - 3 iron atoms to each carbon atom) This is not desirable, since there are large expanses of soft iron between the carbon. An ideal structure would be a very evenly disbursed carbon pattern in the iron, like when the iron/carbon is in the Austenite form.

Through experimentation, man has found that when one cools the steel very rapidly, by quenching the hot steel in oil or water, the carbon does not have time to be squeezed out of the crystal structure of the Ferrite. This special type of Ferrite Iron is known as MARTENSITE.

Martensite
When an Austenite steel cools slowly, it decomposes to Ferrite and Carbide. Austenite (fcc) --> Ferrite (bcc) + Carbide. The steel will be Ferrite iron, with concentrated clumps of Carbides. But if the steel is quenched (cooled quickly), the carbon does not have time to be squeezed out of the iron cells and an unstable transition phase called Martensite is formed. Martensite forms at temperatures well below the eutectoid temperature (See chart on pg 4), but above room temperature. It does not involve a diffusion from Austenite to Ferrite crystals, but rather from a shearing action. All atoms shift in concert, and no individual atom departs more than a fraction from its previous neighbor. Being diffusionless, the change is very rapid. All of the carbon that was present remains in solid solution and does not have a chance to form carbides. The resulting body-centered structure is Tetragonal (bct) rather than cubic. It is definitely different from Ferrite. Since Martensite has a noncubic structure, and since carbon is trapped in the lattice, slip does not occur readily and therefore martensite is hard, strong and brittle. But martensite is a metastable phase and it will always want to decompose to the more stable face centered cubic Ferrite and carbide structure. Martensite (M) ---> Tempered Martensite (Ferrite + Carbide). If left in the martensite state, the steel is hard, but is very brittle and would shatter with use, so it must be tempered.

Tempering is the process, where the steel is heated for 30 minutes or longer (depending on the mass of the part) to 350-500oF. The very unstable Martensite is given time to convert to the more stable Ferrite structure and the carbon is allowed time to squeeze out of the tight lattice spaces, but not enough time to migrate and clump together. The iron (or steel) is now at an ideal structure called tempered Martensite. This is tough, stable Ferrite structure, with hard carbides finely disbursed throughout it. An analogy is a roadbed, pure gravel or pure clay roads do not keep their shape, but mixed finely together, they make a hard durable road surface.
Tempered martensite is much tougher than the metastable martensite, making it a much better, if somewhat softer steel for scissors. With a even dispersion of hard particles within the ductile Ferrite Iron matrix, we obtain a favorable condition called plastic constraint. This is where the carbides inhibit slipping and shearing of the weaker ferrite iron matrix. At the same time, the ductile ferrite iron matrix is tough. Since a progressing crack must travel through this tough matrix, energy is required, giving toughness to the total material, as well as strength. This is similar to a snickers bar. The nuts are the carbon and the nougat is the iron. You can pound on it, but the snickers bar will not break. Take a planters bar though and hit it against the table and it will crack.

Another important element in hardening martensitic steels is the effect of added corrosion resistance. 420 and 440A/C martensitic steels are not stainless or only mildly stainless when annealed (soft)! Free carbides in the non-hardened state reduce corrosion resistance. Because the carbides are dissolved in hardening, the hardened steels have much better corrosion resistance than in the annealed state.

Eutectoid Region of Steel
Steels with about 0.77% Carbon are commonly called EUTECTOID steels. As you can see on chart 4, the stable temperature for Austenite lowers as the carbon content goes from 0% to .77% Carbon. The eutectoid temperature of Iron-carbon alloys is 727oC or 1340oF. The corresponding eutectoid composition is approximately 0.77% carbon.
The eutectoid chart is important, because during the cooling process, the Fe-C eutectoid reaction involves the simultaneous formation of Ferrite and Carbide in a unique microstructure called PEARLITE. Pearlite is a lamellar mixture or alternating layers of 88% ferrite and 12% carbide. Pearlite forms only from austenite of eutectoid composition. Now please refer to chart 4. Say we have a .4% carbon steel. Follow the line from the 0.4% carbon on the bottom straight up. As the 0.4% carbon steel cools from within the Austenite area, it will go thru the triangle on the left hand side of chart, where only Ferrite and Austenite steel will be formed. As the temperature lowers, more and more of the Austenite is converted to Ferrite. But none of the hard carbides are formed until we get below the 727oC point! So from about 810oC to 727oC we only get soft Ferrite iron. Finally at the lower temperatures we will get Ferrite plus Carbides. But if the steel cools too slowly, the Carbides will be formed in the middle of large areas of soft Ferrite. That is bad, as we discussed before. So we must quench the steel, to pass through the triangle on the left as fast as possible, so that we get to the temperatures where Ferrite and Carbide are formed together at the same time uniformly, with the Carbides dispersed finely and evenly throughout the Ferrite. If we quench it fast enough, we will get Martensite Steel!

As alloys are added to the Fe-C mix, the eutectoid temperature and Carbon composition % will change. For example, adding 1% molybdenum to the mix raises the eutectoid temperature from 1340oF to about 1475oF, while lowering the carbon % to .35%. Adding chromium will also raises the eutectoid temperature, while molybdenum lowers it (See chart 5).

STAINLESS STEEL
When you add a certain amount of Chromium to the steel, the steel becomes corrosion resistant. Steel alloys to which a minimum of 11.5% Chromium has been added do not usually form red rusts and so are called "stainless". The Chromium, when in contact with air forms a non-reactive Chromium Oxide film. This passive film protects the surface iron from reacting with oxygen and forming rust. If the surface is scratched, the newly exposed chromium again reacts with the oxygen to form a new film barrier!

The passive chromium oxide film, which may be as thin as a molecule thickness, can lose its protectiveness in reducing environments such as hydrochloric acids, etc. (See list below). Increasing the Chromium content of the stainless steel increases it's protective qualities. Adding Molybdenum also greatly expands the range of environments which are sufficiently oxidizing to maintain a passive film. This means that Molybdenum helps certain environments react easier with the Chromium to oxydize.

The only detriment of Chromium is that it does not harden the iron. Unfortunately, the Chromium must be added in great quantities, because the main hardening agent in steel, Carbon, can react with up to 17 times its own weight of Chromium to form Carbides. Carbides do not resist corrosion. So one needs at least a 18 to 1 ratio of Chromium to Carbon, to have enough free Chromium left over after the reaction, to give the steel its stainless properties! Martensitic stainless steels are limited to 12-18% chromium. Only at this range can a fully Austenitic structure be obtained in the heat treating process. As with Carbon and alloy steels, 100% Austenite is required prior to quenching, if full-hardening response is to be obtained.
To maximize the stainless feature, the surface should be highly buffed. To demonstrate: After grinding, the grit leaves a rough surface which looks like a ragged mountain range under the microscope. Moisture, acids, etc., can be trapped in the cracks and the steel could get rusty. Through buffing, the peaks and valleys are smoothed out, eliminating to a large degree the possibility of entrapment of moisture. The resulting surface of cutlery has a mirror finish.
One of the most common type of corrosion on scissors is pitting. The most common cause of pitting is the lack of cleanliness. If dirt, hair, etc. is allowed to deposit on a stainless surface, the metal directly underneath does not have access to oxygen, which is required to maintain the corrosion-resistant surface film. Molybdenum added to the steel again reduces the chances of pitting.

Chemical Resistance and Attacks
The 400 series stainless steels have moderate resistance to Ethyl Alcohol, Methyl Alcohol, Ammonia, Formaldehyde, Hydrogen Peroxide, Nitric Acid (dyes), Potassium Bicarbonate, Sodium Nitrate and Phosphate, Tannic Acid (inks), most atmospheres including marine.
It is attacked by many other acids including Chlorides (cooking, Halogen Salts, etc.), Acetic Acid (vinegar), Perming solutions, Ammonium Chloride (dry cells), Formic acids (dyes), hydrochloric acids (gastric juice), graphite (causes galvanic corrosion, so do not use as a lubricant). Quad Ammonia and Phenolic disinfectants will rust 400 series if not mixed with a rust inhibitor. High skin acid, especially in women during their period, can cause rusting and discoloration on scissor and nipper handles.

Quenching
Quenching is one of the most important parts of the heat-treating operations. The rate of cooling dictates the structure and properties of the steel. Cool it too slowly and you get too many clumped precipitates. Too fast and the steel will be shocked and be too stressed, resulting in warpage and stress cracks. Stainless barber scissors are usually quenched in heated oil, whereas carbon plated scissors are quenched in either water or oil. Since Austenite steel is denser than Martensite (and also denser than Ferrite plus Carbide), cracking of the material can occur. The slower cooling central region of the scissor forging transforms and expands after the quickly cooled surface has formed brittle Martensite. This is another reason certain alloys such as Molybdenum and Manganese are added to the steel. They allow a steel to be quenched more slowly, while still forming good Martensite.
Quenching Power of Various Media Air Oil Water Brine
Non circulating liquid 0.02 .25 - .30 0.9 - 1.0 2
Mild circulation .30 - .35 1.0 - 1.1 2 - 2.2
The severity of quench is based on a value of 1.0 for still water.
A complication in hardening higher-chromium steels such as the 420 and 440 series, is their tendency for Austenite retention after quenching. Not all of the Austenite shifts to Martensite and the retained Austenite reduces the hardness of the part. Retained Austenite can be converted to Martensite by multiple heat tempering or ice-tempering.

Tempering
In its hardened, "as-quenched" Martensitic form, steel is hard and brittle, with pockets of retained Austenite. The hardened steel must be subsequently tempered to relieve quenching stresses and to provide a limited but necessary degree of toughness and ductility to protect the part from cracking. The higher the temperature or the longer the parts are tempered, the more the steel is stress relieved, and the softer the steel becomes. This is because the carbon will migrate together, forming clumps Carbides with large areas of soft Ferrite in between.
Steel Grain Boundaries

Adjacent groups of crystals have dissimilar orientations, so clumps of similarly oriented cells are called grains (like sand grains on a beach). A steel that has a small grain structure is tougher than one with large grain structures. The longer parts are tempered, the more grain structures grow. (Beaches with fine sand are hard packed, while coarse sand beaches are softer to walk on and give more.) Dar Expo usually tempers their shears for 1-3 hours at 350o to 425o F, depending on the steel. This drops our Rockwell 1-2 points, but adds a tremendous amount of toughness. The shears should then be air cooled to reduce any new stresses from forming.
Multiple tempering is more effective than a single tempering operation for highly alloyed steels. The first treatment tempers the Martensite formed during quenching and conditions some of the retained Austenite to be transformed to Martensite during the cooling process back to room temperature. The second tempering is then necessary to temper the Martensite formed during the first tempering, and so on.

Browning a scissor while sharpening should not degrade the steel hardness. Blueing the steel can soften the scissor edge dramatically though.

Tempering Media
The quenched scissors can be tempered in an environmental oven or a salt pot. The type of tempering media can effect the surface of the steel.
Hydrogen-Nitrogen atmospheres leave bright surfaces when the work is allowed to cool in a low-dew-point hydrogen atmosphere.
Air and Molten Nitrate Salt baths are slightly oxidizing tempering mediums.

Salt Bath Hardening
German styling scissors and industrial scissors are usually fully forged. These forgings are hung by a rack and dipped into a hot salt bath (1650-2000o F) so that the blade and nailhole are submersed. The handle is left out. The scissors are then pulled out and quenched. This creates a very hard blade, with soft handles, that can still be set.

Environmental Chamber Hardening
The scissors are put in a chamber (a fancy oven) and heated up. The entire scissor is heated, so with solid forgings, the handles harden (which is good, since now they become stainless). Some Japanese keep their handles soft by welding a handle made of a stainless alloy that does not harden (300 or 430 series). In all of the heat treating methods described, it is very important to minimize oxygen contact with the parts. Carbon reacts with the oxygen at high temperatures, migrating out of the steel surface. (See decarb).

Induction Hardening
In induction heat treating, a high frequency electric current flowing through an inductor (heating coil) results in an alternating magnetic field which induces a current in the surface layers of a conductive metal part. This allows the very rapid heating of part surfaces, which are then quenched. Normal heat treating principle are applied. Induction hardening is used to harden only the edge on scissors, or to anneal and soften handles on scissors, so that they can be set or processed. This is an inexpensive and fast way to harden the edges of a scissor, but is usually reserved for less expensive scissors.

Surface hardening
Gas carburizing is a standard method of increasing the outer case carbon content of the scissor by a process of absorption. Usually a 20% Carbon monoxide/ 40% hydrogen/40% nitrogen mixture is introduced to a chamber and the steel is heated above it's upper critical temperature (steel is in 100% austenite state). The time and temperature control how deep the carburizing case goes. One of the major reactions are:
3 Fe + 2 CO --> Fe3C +CO2
3Fe + CO + H2 --> Fe3C + H20 We now have our Iron Carbide (Fe3C) case.

Decarb
In scissor making, a principal unwanted reaction is the combination of carbon and oxygen to form CO gas. If the forging steel comes in contact with oxygen during forging, heat treating or annealing, the carbon will react with the oxygen and dissipate into the atmosphere, resulting in an outside decarbed layer of steel. We have seen scissors with a 0.040" decarb layer. This is a soft iron layer, with very little carbon in it. This will result in the scissor edges cutting into each other and dulling very quickly.

Some steels from 3rd world countries or less expensive steels have not been "killed" during processing. The oxygen and carbon form gases permeated throughout a steel. In cast scissors, this creates "Rimmed Steels", which are characterized by marked differences in chemical composition across the section. The outer rim is lower in carbon, phosphorus and sulfur and the core is higher in these elements. In some instances this can be desirable, but not for scissors. A scissor will decarb 0.010-0.015 inch per 2 hours in a tempering oven, if the environment is oxygen rich. That is why Dar Expo scissors are always processed in environmental chambers with no free oxygen.

Rust
The oxidation of iron produces iron ions and electrons. The electrons combine with oxygen and water to form (OH)- ions. Rust contains a combination of Fe3+ and (OH)-.
Anode: Fe-->Fe3+ +3e-
Cathode: 3e- + 3/2H2O + 3/4O2 --> 3(OH)- Hydroxyde
Precipitation: Fe3+ + 3(OH)- --> Fe(OH)3
The hydrated form of the final product, Fe(OH)3, is insoluble in water and therefore precipitates. It is rust and it will form on iron in air even if no more than an absorbed layer of moisture is present as an electrolyte.

ALLOYS
Alloying elements are added to basic steels to enhance corrosion resistance, hardness, toughness and processibility.
Carbon - carbon is the principal hardener in steel. The more carbon that is added (up to 1.2%), the harder it gets. Higher amounts of carbons create high levels of cementite (Fe3C) and go under various names such as white iron, etc.
Phosphorus and Sulfur are present in all steels, usually as impurities, but they are sometimes added in controlled amounts for easier machining.
Molybdenum - This is one of the most important additives. Molybdenum adds toughness and increases corrosion resistance to withstand industrial chemicals and solvents and inhibits pitting caused by chlorides. Molybdenum also lengthens the quench time of a steel, so that a good, stressfree martensitic structure can be formed. Molybdenum also inhibits grain growth.
Cobalt - Cobalt scissors come in two types. Forged steel and Powder or Sintered Metal. The powdered metals give the maximum cobalt benefit, but are VERY susceptible to breaking. Never set or bend a cobalt scissor, unless you enjoy buying your customer a new one. The powder metal cobalt alloy demonstrates outstanding mechanical properties and cutting performance. Powder metal Cobalt scissors are usually composed of a 50% Co (Cobalt) - 28.7% Fe (Iron) -20% W (Tungsten) - 1.3% C (Carbon) alloy. These alloys attain an untempered maximum value of 66 to 67 Rc. Forged Cobalt tools are much tougher than sintered metals, but seldom have more than 10% cobalt in them, making them softer with rockwells around 58Rc.
Manganese contributes to strength and hardness. The amount of increase is dependent on the amount of carbon present. The more carbon in a steel, the higher the effect of manganese. Manganese is beneficial for the surface finish of a part, especially if the steel is high in sulfur.
Phosphorus - increases strength and hardness, but at the sacrifice of ductility and impact toughness, if added in too great a quantity.
Sulfur - Detrimental to surface finish in high quantities. Improves machinability
Silicon - principal deoxidizer used in steelmaking. It also increases strength and hardness.
Chromium - Protects against corrosion and adds heat resistance. Decreases strength and hardness. Must be at about a 18:1 ratio with carbon, since the carbon can take from the alloy about 17 times its own weight of chromium to form carbides. This chromium in the form of carbides is of little use for resisting corrosion.
Carbon Steel - Steel is considered carbon steel, when no minimum content is specified or required of chromium, molybdenum, vanadium, nickel, tungsten or any other element added. The following elements do not exceed 1.65% manganese, 0.60% silicon, or 0.60% copper.
Vanadium - Adds toughness and fatigue resistance.
Nickel improves corrosion resistance and toughness. Allows higher chromium alloys to fully harden. Types 414 and 431 are the most corrosive resistant of the martensitic steels.

Hot Drop Forged vs. Blanked
What is a drop forged shear? Pieces of steel are heated up red hot and put in a die that looks somewhat like a cake form in the shape of the shear or tool. Half of the form is fastened to a big anvil, the other half of the die is attached to the ram which acts like a hammer. The ram comes down on the steel, forging the pliable steel into the die and giving the steel the form of the future shear. These drop hammers are up to 20 feet high, standing on a 10-foot deep foundation. The ram can weigh 1000 lbs. or more. Because of variances in dimensions of the shears, some of the hot steel is being squeezed out of the die cavity. This creates a large burr which is cut off under heavy presses. Now the still hot shear forgings are cooled off under controlled conditions to eliminate any internal stress. They are then tempered and trimmed.

What is a blanked shear? Most less expensive shears are blanked out. Strips of steel are cut out in the form of a shear, like rolled cookie dough is shaped with cookie cutters. The cheaper version of the "Blanked" shears are then ground into shape. For a better quality the cut out "Blanks" are put into a powerful press and the blade is squeezed into shape. Thereby the steel near the edge is compressed and the cutting edges last longer. This means, that not all cheaper shears are equally cheap. Drop forged tools and shears are far superior to blanked ones. The material flow of the hot metal being forged and pounded into the cavity gives the steel a much denser structure, better quality and ultimately longer life.

TESTING METHODS
Here are several quick test methods to be used by sharpeners.
Spark Tests Don't quite know what type of steel you have there? With experience, spark testing can tell you a lot. From now on, check the sparks given off by every repair you do. Carbon steel scissors that can rust will spark bright white. Cast industrial scissors that you should not bend will spark dark red. Stainless scissors will spark just a little bit bright white or yellowish. Decarbed surfaces will not spark much at all. You can save yourself a lot of trouble and broken scissors by being aware of the little spark.

Chemical Spot Test - One part Nitric Acid/one part water - Does not attack hardened stainless steels. Good way to see if scissor is stainless. Also shows spots where there is no plating. Nitric acid also lightly attacks annealed stainless 400 series. Good way to see what is hard.
Another method to test for decarb is to make up a batch of Nital. Nitric Acid (3-5%) and Methanol mixed together will make a pronounced white ring in decarbed areas of a polish material. You see a dark ring on decarbed areas of case hardened steels. Nital etches in 3-5 seconds.

Another easy mix of 50% Hydrochloric Acid with water heated to 150oF. Submerse the part in this solution for 30 minutes. You will now see defined decarb and stress areas.

Magnet Test - 420 and 440 Stainless steels are magnetic. 300 series are not.

Hardness Tests - A rockwell hardness tester measures the difference in the depth of penetration of a diamond or steel ball tipped penetrator subjected to a minor (initial) and a major (final) load under specific conditions. The deeper the diamond penetrates, the softer the material is. The penetration is approximately 0.00008 inch per Rc point. So dirt, plating or decarb on the outside surface of a shear can really throw off a Rockwell reading.

Many inexpensive stainless scissors are made from 410 SS. 410 is easy to work, has excellent corrosion resistance, but will harden to only 38-44Rc. Beware of these scissors, they will not keep an edge long. Bend away, you usually can do this with your bare hands.
420 was one of the first stainless steels developed, made primarily for the cutlery industry. It is still one of the most widely used steels for scissors. Most German scissors are 420. It hardens to 48-55 Rc, has good ductility and toughness. Most 420 scissors are hardened to ~51-52 Rc. At this hardness the blades can be bent and set, without much fear of breakage. Many of the 420 steels come in a High Carbon version (up to .50% carbon).

440 series of stainless steels quench to a rockwell between 56-62Rc. Tempered, they usually perform the best in the 54-57Rc range. 57+ and they become very brittle. Most clam shell scissors are made out of modified 440 series steels.

Difference Between German Barber Scissors & Japanese Barber Scissors

What is a Japanese Style Scissor? Is it different than a German style scissor? Is one better than the other for different uses? Is there a difference in caring for different scissors?

These are a few of many questions constantly asked in the beauty industry. We will highlight these questions in this article.

The Edge: Japanese style scissors have very sharp edges that taper to a sharp point called a convex edge. These edges are very thin and sharp allowing the user to cut all techniques, including slide cuts, wisping, etc. Because the edges are so sharp, they would rub themselves dull on the hollow side of the edge. To keep this from happening, a hone line is ground in the hollow along the edge. The hone line is the thin flat line that you see on the hollow side of the edge that runs from the tip of the scissor to the back. This gives the scissor a smooth and quiet run. If we did not grind on a hone line, the scissor would run hard and loud. (The run is the feel and function of opening and closing a scissor). If a scissor sharpener does not sharpen and re-hone your scissor correctly, the scissor will never feel like when it was new. But if sharpened correctly, the scissor often feels and cuts better than when it was new!

A German scissor has flatter edges than a convex scissor. We call this a sword or bevel edge. Bevel edges are not as angled as a convexed edge, thus requiring one or both edges to be serrated or corrugated. A serration are fine lines or teeth ground into the edge of one blade. The serration holds the hair, keeping it from being pushed forward.

Now we come to the performance differences between the Japanese (convex edge) and German (bevel edge) scissors. Because of its very sharp edges, the convex scissor cuts through hair smoothly and efficiently, with less force. The convex scissor is constructed for slide cutting or wisping. It runs smoothly, quietly, and very lightly. However, it has the tendency to nick and dull faster than a bevel edge scissor. It also has a tendency to push the hair more than a serrated bevel edge scissor.

The bevel scissor is very durable. It holds the hair very well and does not push it forward. It is the scissor of choice for blunt and layer cutting, dry cutting and for the cutting of synthetic and coarse hair. Its major drawbacks are that one cannot slide cut with it, because of the serration, and it runs louder and rougher than a convex scissor.

So we rate the scissors as follows:
Bevel edge scissors:
Slide cutting / wisping 5 Layer cuts / Scissor over comb 10
Convex edge scissors:
Slide cutting / wisping 10 Layer cuts / Scissor over comb 9